Fernando Díaz López COP31 interview transcript SIGNATURE TUNE Hello and welcome to this special Breakthroughs podcast devoted to the 31st summit of the Conference of the Parties, better known as COP31. Today’s HEC Paris guest is: “ Hello, my name is Fernando Javier Díaz López. I’m the Executive Director for Climate at the Sustainability & Organizations Centre of HEC Paris. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVDCzVGMD0c “Excellencies…. This year… I’m not saying we’re winning the climate fight. But we are undeniably still in it, and we are fighting back. Here in Belem, nations chose unity, science and economic common sense.” That was UN Executive Secretary Simon Stiell closing COP30 in Belém, Brazil, exactly a year ago. Well, as COP31 gets going in the Turkish city of Antalya, just how much has this unity, science and economic common sense helped to achieve? Admittedly, countries did agree on 59 indicators for measuring adaptation. And COP30 did instigate a call for loss-and-damage funding – and that drew requests covering 119 countries. But the UN says that even tripling adaptation finance by 2035 would meet less than a third of developing countries’ needs. And the fossil-fuel roadmap unveiled just last week, well, is purely voluntary. So, what would turn those commitments into protection from the Superniño brewing in the Pacific, or the extreme variations in climate we’ve been experiencing? And what can the Global South teach Europe about solutions that already exist? In the first of two Breakthroughs conversations, climate researcher and IPCC author Fernando Díaz López explains what his research can tell us about adaptation, and where its limits lie. We broadcast this edition on the eve of the Leaders Summit; that’s part of the two-week COP31 in Antalya that started on November 9th . The two-day gathering of world leaders is when the summit truly shifts into high gear. Well, before reflecting on what these lawmakers want or can do, I asked Fernando what he hopes COP31 can achieve over these twelve days.. F002 COP31 expectations and research [00:13] Fernando Well, cautiously optimistic is the right phrasing in my mind. COP31 has been labelled as a Conference of the Parties that moves from pledges to implementation. And this is actually exciting. COP30 in Belém had interesting developments, and at the Santa Marta conference a coalition of governments wanted to decrease dependency on fossil fuels. COP31 is particularly interesting because it’s the launch of the second global stocktake on the Paris Agreement. It’s also a COP that will be looking a lot at implementation and delivery, climate finance, adaptation and just transition. All of that is a reason to be optimistic. When you look at the policy priorities of the presidency, you look at electrification, zero waste and methane reduction. Everybody focuses on carbon. [01:30] Fernando Here there is an explicit focus on methane, which, in the short term, is a fantastic solution to deal with greenhouse gas emissions. We also expect a lot of discussions around climate-resilient cities and buildings and green industrialisation. This is a topic close to my heart and my work in the IPCC Seventh Assessment Report. We will also be expecting a lot on food security. Now, this is all wonderful news, but at the same time, the geopolitical realities don’t necessarily allow me to be overly optimistic. [02:17] Fernando When I was interviewed for the previous COP, I was saying, “Yes, this is a COP of implementation.” Yeah, well, it wasn't. So now we are moving from pledges to action, turning commitments into real impact on the ground. And that in itself has; you can come up with frameworks and more of these high-level ambitions. But how governments take this into practice, how you really work with civil society, with industry, with investors: that’s really where the challenge begins. Now, I am also cautiously optimistic because the IPCC’s 65th session in Addis Ababa reached an impasse. There was no agreement on the timeline for the IPCC reports, or on the budget for next year. If people ask me, “What is your ideal outcome?” there are many ideal outcomes. But personally, because of the process I am involved in at the IPCC, I would expect governments to send a really strong political signal supporting AR7 before the second global stocktake. That means 2028. [03:40] Daniel 2028. Fernando, you’ve spent decades doing research on the topics you brought up. How does COP31 connect with that research on climate adaptation and resilience? And what are you hoping will change? [04:11] Fernando For my own research, I’ve spent a great deal of time working on industrial decarbonisation, circularity and green innovation. It was about five or six years ago when I realised you cannot just do climate mitigation and expect environmental pollution to be the only thing that moves our attention. It was because climate risks were becoming more materialised, and I understood that you need a combination of climate mitigation and adaptation. This is a concept called climate-resilient development: implementing mitigation and adaptation solutions in alignment with the Sustainable Development Goals. Let’s not forget the 2030 Agenda and the Sustainable Development Goals. As I mentioned, there will be a lot of conversations at COP about green industrialisation, for example. That is the bulk of my research: how industry, how intermediaries, governments and companies themselves can design strategies to decarbonise. More and more—and this is something you will see at this COP—there is already a global goal adaptation having been launched, and this COP will pay a lot of attention to metrics and indicators. This is where my second block of research comes in: understanding how you can assess, monitor and better understand adaptation and resilience, first at the territorial level, and second in connection with public and private actors. And what it actually means to understand outcomes and results. Until now, most of the frameworks that exist tell you, “We have extreme heat. It’s more frequent, it’s more intense, the consequences are visible.” But we are not able to tell, if you implement an adaptation solution—for example, a green roof or mangrove restoration next to a coastline— what does it do to your value chain? What does it do to your house? What does it do to your government programme for canteens in schools? This is what we call outcomes. It’s not only looking at what goes in, what goes through. But what is the result? This is what my research is about. This is a central topic not only at COP31. Just a couple of days ago, the European Commission launched a proposal for a new regulation on climate resilience. There has also been a communication from the European Commission to Parliament on an integrated framework on climate adaptation and resilience. The backbone of that is measuring. This is really the topic. I think this is not only relevant, but I use the many different experiences of measuring the green economy, circular economy and industrial decarbonisation. Now, let’s take the challenge of measuring climate adaptation and resilience in the context of climate-resilient development, meaning mitigation and adaptation aligned with the Sustainable Development Goals. 9.00 Daniel How urgent is it to start implementing and looking at something that’s been a bit neglected in the past? Fernando Well, it depends who you ask. If you ask people the insurance sector, they will tell you we are already decades late. They have developed their own models and systems—not only insurance, but the financial sector at large. That’s why a lot of the discussion, not only at COPs but in many forums, is about climate finance. It’s important that investment or finance, whether public or private, is not only ready but actually allocated to the right solution. What is the expression in English? You don’t bet on the wrong horse. There is a fundamental logic to this opportunity to measure and assess better, because we cannot really understand the size of the problem if we don’t create a baseline, a benchmark and a way of assessing what can be done, where to intervene, which solutions to use and on what timeline. I don’t think it’s been totally neglected. Some sectors, actors like governments and international organizations have been talking about measurement. The OECD has been insisting for a long time on the need to measure adaptation better. Some sectors, like agriculture and water, are more developed compared with heavy industry. [10:26] This is where not only the discussions in these political forums, but also the research we do day to day, are important. F004 Small businesses and UNDERPIN JINGLE [00:03] Daniel Fernando, let’s come back to COP31. In one of dozens of workshops at COP31, there will be discussions on getting local adaptation projects funded. Where should a small business with little money or climate expertise start? [00:20] Fernando Here again, I’m talking only from the perspective of Europe. It’s not the perspective of Africa or Mexico, or other countries very close to my heart. At COP, finance will be a big topic. You always talk about mobilising the private sector for climate finance. A small business owner will not be mobilising resources towards the global goal on adaptation. They need their own resources to deal with their own risks. That’s thing number one. Second, in Europe the integrated climate adaptation and resilience framework becomes very relevant because a few years ago the Committee of the Regions estimated that about 80% of climate adaptation solutions are implemented at the local level. It has to do with the level of autonomy in managing financial resources that we have in Europe. You have completely autonomous regions in Spain, for example the Basque Country or Catalonia. In general, French regions also have a lot of autonomy in how they manage their resources. There are EU-level mechanisms like the Cohesion Fund and the Just Transition Fund, in addition to funding at the national level. COP31 will also talk about the new collective quantified goal on finance. Again, we’re talking about international climate diplomacy. You have multinational actors and companies taking part in those discussions. The International Chamber of Commerce is following all those discussions very closely. But in general, financial planning is a matter for an individual entrepreneur. It’s a matter for a small business owner, a medium-sized company, or a unicorn. Here we distinguish broadly between two groups: companies in the business of creating and selling those solutions—entrepreneurs and start-ups—and companies that need to incorporate them because they need to adapt and transform. For a small business owner, financial planning can only be effective once you prioritise which innovations, actions and specific solutions you will implement, or which ones have more market opportunity to be sold. It goes back to prioritisation and climate planning. Small companies don’t do that. Small companies need to pay salaries and comply with taxes. They need to be on time for the delivery of purchase orders. And all this complex jargon of “you need to do your climate”, etcetera… If you talk to a lot of alumni or small business owners, they know it will affect them, but they don’t know how to deal with it. Going back to the COP31, this is really where national governments and multilateral and international organisations play a role, because programmes that can help small business owners adapt and prepare better are urgent. I take the analogy of what has happened for many years across the world with UNIDO and UN Environment creating a global network of cleaner production centres, dealing with decarbonising and avoiding environmental pollution at large—not only CO₂ but also heavy metals and other things. It starts with capacity-building, not of the companies, but of the intermediaries that work with companies to support them. A large company here in France will have the support of AXA Climate, Carbone 4, EcoAct or Schneider to do its climate adaptation and climate mitigation plans. Small business owners cannot afford that. Intermediary organizations like our own CDL program, the Creative Destruction Lab, to bring that solution to market and find the right investor. So we’re talking about the need for intermediation and connectivity in local ecosystems of adaptation solutions. This is where international forums like COP can make a big difference. But I’m not entirely sure this is in the pipeline for discussions at this level of operationalisation. Certainly actors at COP, like UNIDO, UNDP, UN Environment, Chambers of Commerce or development agencies like the French Development Agency, can step up and play a role. YOUTUBE EXTRACT? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ITspGjoyhFw F005 Global South knowledge and heat 16.00: Fernando Díaz López, COP31 will obviously look at heat, especially extreme heat. You suggested low-cost, high-efficiency solutions that are really interesting for me and for listeners: white roofs, natural airflow, earth-based bricks. These can offer useful solutions at low cost and are often developed or implemented in Latin America or sub-Saharan Africa. Are people listening to these proposals and ideas? [00:49] Fernando That’s a really interesting question. It goes back to my roots as someone who grew up in a very different environment from where I live now. I’m originally from Mexico. In Mexico, we have the adobe house. Basically, it’s bricks made out of earth. This type of construction, which has existed for many centuries, is based a lot— Daniel Pre-Columbian, even? Fernando Yes, it’s based on Indigenous peoples’ knowledge. I myself have heritage from the [“Masagua” people — Mazahua? U22] in Mexico, through my grandparents and my mother. There is a way you relate to the world and to your natural environment, because you’re part of it. You are not the owner of it. Many of these solutions are low tech, and many make perfect sense. There are eco movements built around building naturally. I use these examples to illustrate the tension and opportunities between mitigation and adaptation, because one of the big problems in our society is overconsumption. We consume more, and more often. The more disposable income we have, the more unsustainable activities we end up purchasing, financing or indirectly supporting. Cost-efficient solutions based on low tech are not very difficult to find. Right now in Seville— let me finish the story, the example of adobe. The thermal coefficient of adobe and the way the houses are built: you have very thick walls. In the desert, in northern Mexico, there have been 50 degrees Celsius during the day, so they know extreme heat and extreme cold, because at night it gets to minus three or minus four degrees Celsius. This type of construction keeps the heat out during the day and allows residual heat to go inside the house at night. The adobe house was presented at an international forum last year on sustainable habitat as a best practice in construction. In the Americas, as you know, there are areas with earthquakes. In Peru, they also use adobe, and they have developed a technical standard to create adobe bricks that are resistant or prepared for earthquakes. Why is this relevant? It’s a Global South innovation. There’s a concept we are studying right now in a master’s thesis: reverse innovation. This has happened with frugal innovation solutions in India that ended up coming to Europe, the US and other places. [19.19] The thesis asks how transferable they are. France has developed certain technical standards for air TIGHT bricks, which are being tested, but without the same properties as adobe. You have probably two-thirds or half of the thermal properties of adobe. Certainly, they are not certified or prepared for earth movements. Why is this relevant? In Île-de-France and in France, I think probably 60% of the territory is clay soil. [Geography and denominator to check, U27] With extreme heat, soils contract. During rainy seasons, because we have more water than we used to have, the clay expands, and that expansion and contraction of soil damages property. If you look at insurance claims in the last few years, and the number of [natural catastrophes declared? U28] by municipalities in France, you already have an issue. Would a solution like this be interesting for France or Île-de-France? Maybe it’s worth investigating. Another example relating to extreme heat: not everybody knows Paris has an underground water cooling system in public buildings and museums. There’s a public company” that manages it, There has been a massive debate in France about air-conditioning systems. The known effect is that you remove heat from your apartment, but it goes into the street, contributing to the existing problem of the heat-island effect. There’s a concentration of heat, aggravated by not having enough trees and building with concrete, cement and asphalt. [20.30] Fernando In Seville, there’s a new development in the Cartuja district implementing a natural underground airflow system based on an ancient Persian technology. Centuries old. [06:36] Daniel So authorities in Seville are listening to these kinds of imports from Latin America? [06:41] Fernando In this case, from North Africa and the Middle East, because these are also regions that have historically dealt with extreme heat. There are new design principles in the Cartuja project, but we’re talking about principles of heat exchange, airflows, “cold and air flows”. The technology and knowledge are centuries old, based on local and traditional knowledge. Is this a topic that will be debated at COP31? It’s likely: the role of Indigenous peoples, Indigenous knowledge, etcetera. Certainly, in the IPCC Seventh Assessment Report, when you look at the approved outline, [21.40] Fernando Indigenous peoples’ knowledge is part of it. This is good news, I think. Does it make business sense? This is something business schools like ours can help investigate. But there’s also another aspect of what COP31 will be doing: they will be talking a lot about just transition. It’s about creating a better-adapted and more climate-resilient situation for all, but also not leaving people behind. With reverse innovation, we need to make sure that, when we identify the transferability of these solutions, the benefits and wellbeing stay with the original manufacturer. There are many cases in biotechnology, the bioeconomy and medicines where traditional knowledge has been extracted. Large entities and investors have benefited without remunerating or respecting the rights and ownership of the knowledge that resides in Indigenous peoples and local communities. [22:47] Daniel So COP31 does have an agenda incorporating these solutions, proposals or experiences coming from the Global South. What about Europe? Has it opened up too? You talked about France and perhaps misguided proposals or solutions, on air conditioning that push aside certain consequences. Are they listening? Is the EU listening? Are they trying to implement proposals or experiences from Africa, Latin America or India? [09:24] Fernando That’s a question I don’t know the answer to. What I can tell you is that Europe is probably not so concerned, because we don’t have an endowment of traditional knowledge in Europe, except for the Sámi people in the Nordics. We certainly have a lot of local knowledge and citizen science initiatives. From the angle of citizen science, there is a movement, whether it’s created or supported by the European Commission, national or local governments, or simply because people are taking control of the solutions space, maybe it’s at the local level that these things are happening, or are likely to happen, with more positive benefits. It’s certainly something we need to keep a closer eye on, to know if Europe, and in particular the European Commission… and of course I have a bias towards research and innovation. Maybe there should be some new research about this. F008 Outcomes and short term versus long term [24.20] Daniel Fernando, what concrete outcome from COP31 in Turkey could make a difference for the companies and communities you study, research and work with? [00:14] Fernando I think the policy priorities of this COP—electrification, zero waste and methane reduction…. Climate-resilient cities, food security. Personally, if COP really moves from pledges to “this is a roadmap”, with discussion of what it means for the next cycle of implementation on the ground, at scale, for example the just transition mechanism and programme, I think we will be making [progress? U37]. I really hope this COP sends a political signal that AR7, the Seventh Assessment Report of the IPCC, is ready before the second global stocktake. Also, that there is enough willingness and action to strengthen the IPCC’s financial position towards the Eighth Assessment Report. You’ve probably seen in the Nature editorial that this is a concern. I think this COP should create momentum for COP32 and COP33, so that governments really strengthen their level of ambition. There have been a lot of conversations about breaking away from fossil fuels, new metrics, new this, new that. What does it mean in practice? We need more than plans for decarbonising or adapting. You have national plans and nationally determined contributions; the NAMAs, which are more operational for mitigation. All of that is great: governments have ambition. But when you look into the details of how you do it, it’s not always clear who is responsible for doing it. If this COP comes with a clear agenda translating these political priorities into who should do what, there will be a great… I wouldn’t use the term “success”, but it’s the impetus that’s needed. [03:03] Daniel Underlying our whole exchange is a tension: short-termism against long-termism. That’s where politics come in: politicians’ vision is immediate results, immediacy towards investment. That’s where supranational bodies like the United Nations and COP have their importance. How do you live with that tension as a scientist, looking beyond the vote and the immediate results politicians demand or they sink? [03:43] Fernando One of the reasons I started my journey into a sustainability- and climate-oriented career: when I was 15, I decided I would do a PhD. I didn’t know what it was, but I understood it was important, because I wanted to find solutions to clean the pollution in the river in my hometown. I was even on a local council when I was very young, exposed to local and national decision-makers. I remember these promises: “We’ll make cleaning the river a priority.” There were many attempts, wastewater treatment plants, but they never tackled the source of the problem. [04:35] Fernando The source was a highly [polluted/polluting industrial estate driven by overconsumption. That tension between short-termism and long-termism: I’m no longer 15 with aspirations to clean the river. In the role I have now as a scientist in France, in the international science–policy process that I’m in, but especially as a father, the anxiety it gives me—you’ve probably heard the term “eco-anxiety”, which our young generation, but also people like you and me, experience— comes from this tension. You need to ensure sustainable and climate-resilient development for all, but tackle what is most pressing and urgent. I sympathize with and understand decision-makers when they have so many competing priorities. But if the house is burning, if your factory is flooded, if your local council is no longer adapted and the health of people working in your building is being affected, if the local nursery isn’t adapted to the climate, there is a sense of emergency we’ve never witnessed before. And I know it’s easy for me to ask as a scientist, but short-termism shouldn’t be the priority. It should be: how do we address the impacts and ensure outcomes are more aligned with equity, sustainability, climate resilience, a just transition and a just and equitable situation for all? It’s a tension. I don’t have solutions in my hand. Fortunately, I’m very privileged to be in a job or career path where I can put my mind and thoughts at the service of decision-making that can make a difference. That’s at least what I can tell you, Daniel. Hopefully the future will be bright. [07:06] Daniel Moving from cleaning up a river in a Mexican community to cleaning up the planet, perhaps. Thank you very much, Fernando Díaz López. [07:17] Fernando Thank you. Thank you, Daniel. Fernando Díaz López, speaking to me from his office at HEC Paris, where he’s Executive Director for Climate in the Sustainability and Organization Center ……. As COP31 continues to dominate media attention, the test it must answer is what changes for people already living with climate risk. In part two of Breakthroughs, we’ll examine the decisions behind business adaptation. That’s to say, how regions turn plans into investment, where small firms can find practical support and whether climate dashboards give non-specialists information they can actually use. Fernando also explores how to move beyond responding to the next emergency towards changing the systems that keep producing vulnerability. But until then, there’s just time to thank you for listening to Breakthroughs, our monthly HEC Paris podcast. I’m Daniel Brown and if you want to send in your questions or comments, it’s simple: write to brownd@hec.FR. That’s brownd@hec.FR in one word. Till next time, goodbye…